As a consequence, even in the absence of european harmonisation measures secondary eu legislation, member. The single european act from 1987 introduced qualified majority voting for most harmonisation in the internal market. Harmonisation appears in the context of eu employment and industrial relations as an eu objective, originally stipulated in article 117 of the eec treaty of 1957, now in article 151tfeu. The treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu came into force on 1 december 2009 following the ratification of the treaty of lisbon, which made amendments to the treaty on european union and the treaty establishing the european community tec. Free movement of goods articles 28 30 ec and mutual. As from 1 december 2009, the lisbon treaty significantly revised and renamed the treaty on the functioning of the european union. In order for a csa not to be caught by article 34 tfeu it must fall equally on all traders in the national territory and affect the same in law and in fact in other words it must not be discriminatory. Glossarytreaty on the functioning of the european union tfeurelated contentone of the two main treaties that form the basis of eu law.
In 2019 ewhc 2951 admin friends of antique cultural treasures v secretary of state for the environment, food and rural affairs, justice jay jay j even though correct might sound a bit too intimate upheld the uks planned ban on ivory trade, stricter than. See ramona ianus and massimo orzan, aid subject to a discretionary assessment under article 1073 tfeu in h hoffman and c micheau eds, state aid law of the european union oxford university press 2016 304. And while the principle of subsidiarity embodies that when possible and reasonable, decision making power stays with the member states, the european union does have a mandate and obligation in the policy domain of public health. Contrary to the prevailing view, it is argued in this article that, because this private body was acting on behalf of the. Article 245 ex article 2 tec the members of the commission shall refrain from any action incompatible with their duties. The provision which is the focus of this article is article 34 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu or treaty formerly article 28 ec. The prohibition of discriminatory taxation, abolition of customs duties and removal of other administrative rules and barriers which hinder the free movement of goods have been tackled by articles 34 and 35 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu. Healthcare governance within the european union is predominantly a competence of the individual member states. The scope and application of eu law in this area is largely a result of the court of justice of the european union s activism. Customs union of the european union article 28, tfeu lewik. Finally, article 36 tfeu allows member states to apply rules prohibited under article 34 provided they are justified on the grounds of public morality, public policy, public security, protection of health and life of humans, animals or plants, protection of national treasures possessing artistic historic or archaeological value, or protection. Commission interpretative communication on the application of article 296 of the treaty in the field of defence procurement. Article 346 and the qualified application of eu law to defence.
Pdf subsidiarity as a limit to the exercise of eu competences. Article 262 tfeu the internal market shall comprise an area without internal frontiers in which the free movement of goods, persons, services and capital is ensured in accordance with the provisions of the treaties. Importantly, the field of application of article 34 tfeu is limited by the keck jurisprudence, which states that. Dassonville cadmus eui research repository european. Consolidated version of the treaty on the functioning of the european union 2012 oj c 326, article 34. Feb 28, 20 while chapters 2 and 3 have sought to outline the overall procedures and functioning of article 114 tfeu by scrutinising each of its constituent clauses in turn, the current chapter aims instead to assess how the notification procedure within article 11449 tfeu has been deployed in practice. Free movement of goods fact sheets on the european union. Approximation of laws article 26 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu sets out the aim to establish and to ensure the functioning of the internal market. Eu regulations policies article 346 of the tfeu consolidated versions of the treaty on european union and the treaty on the functioning of the european union. The article is a commentary to article 215 tfeu, which governs the adoption of restrictive measures by the european union. Common customs tariff duties article 31, tfeu framework for the activity of the european commission in carrying out the tasks of the customs union article 32, tfeu measures to strengthen customs cooperation between member states and the commission article 33, tfeu prohibition of quantitative restrictions on imports article 34, tfeu. When the eu internal market was established, goods accounted for more than. In the eu, nontariff barriers are prohibited under articles 34 and 35 tfeu. Restrictions on use and the circular lifecycle of article 34 tfeu.
The treaty on the functioning of the eu tfeu, under article 1, specifically provides for the council, acting unanimously in accordance with a special legislative procedure and after consulting the european parliament and the economic and social committee, to adopt provisions for the harmonisation of member states rules in the area of. Critically discuss the interpretation of the prohibition in article 34 tfeu and its interpretation for the regulation of markets question the court of justice has adopted far too wide an interpretation of the prohibition in article 34 tfeu whilst not going far enough in its interpretation of that article to accommodate the right of member states to regulate their own markets and to pursue. In orgacom v vlaamse landmaatschappij, case c254, the ecj sent out its regular reminder of the core foundation of eu law. However, research indicates that this usually involves reference only to article 1062 tfeu. Article 83 tfeu is the fundamental provision as far as the harmonisation of substantive criminal law is.
Until now, the court has always denied horizontal direct effect of the free movement of goods provisions, in contrast to the other fundamental freedoms. Apr 22, 20 a measure which is not capable of hindering trade between member states, but only affects the flow of trade within a member state will not breach article 34 tfeu. European union tfeu, as those treaties are amended by the treaty of lisbon, with the articles of the existing teu and tec. Apr 08, 2015 tagged article 114 tfeu, centre of european law, charter of fundamental rights, eu constitutional law, european rights and european wrongs, inaugural lecture, kings college london, takis tridimas search for. The lecture is delivered by professor erika szyszczak. Oxford university press online resource centre essay question. In the seminal case of dassonville the scope of article 34 tfeu was cast very wide, indeed its potential breadth is striking. Many international standards from standard organisations become eu law with supremacy over national law when the eu enters into an international agreement.
The treaty on the functioning of the eu tfeu, under article 1, specifically provides for the council, acting unanimously in accordance with a special legislative procedure and after consulting the european parliament and the economic and social committee, to adopt provisions for the harmonisation of member states rules in the area of indirect taxation principally value. On the basis of established case law of the court of justice, however, it is now clear that this is instead a casebycase derogation that is to be applied strictly in excep. Treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu. This is a series of eu law lectures on four freedoms of the eus single market. Under the founding treaty of rome harmonisation of national laws required unanimity. Article 34 tfeu interpretation regulation of markets. Article 63 tfeu is the main treaty article on the freedom of capital movements. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Discuss critically the instability at the heart of article 34 tfeu caselaw and consider whether weatherill is right to be so wary. Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of nationality. Article 6 tfeu lists the areas where the eu has competence to carry out actions to support, coordinate or supplement the actions of the member states, but these larger. Paragraph 2 of the article 26 establishes that the internal market shall comprise an area without.
Article 11 ex article 6 tec environmental protection requirements must be integrated into the definition and implementation of the union policies and activities, in particular with a view to promoting sustainable development. Hot on the heels of yesterdays post on ecollars, a short note on yet another trade and animal welfare biodiversity case. These four freedoms belong to all citizens of the eu, still they often seem. The 1 catherine barnard, the substantive law of the eu oup 20, page 15. Declaration on article 155 and 6, article 176 and 7 and article 18 of the treaty on european union.
Jan 26, 2018 containing an article by article overview of eu competition law jurisprudence and concise selected extracts from judgments in key cases, this book serves as an easy to navigate resource for practitioners, academics and competition authorities themselves. Free movement of goods is a fundamental eu principle and key to economic integration. Importantly, the field of application of article 34 tfeu is limited by the keck. See also number of eu rules, environmental clause, supporting action and voting in the council note. Eurlex, treaty on the functioning of the european union consolidated version 2012, nice table with many links to preamble, articles, protocols, annexes and declarations, in several formats such as pdf and html. Facilitating infringements of article 34 tfeu and the.
In this very interesting grand chamber judgment, the court found swedens scheme promoting the national production of green electricity in accordance with directive 200928, the socalled res directive to be compatible with article 34 tfeu. Article 114 tfeu are challenged in the court of justice of the european union cjeu since the measures in question are considered not to fulfil the objectives on the establishment and functioning of the internal market that article 114 tfeu requires. Article 6 tfeu does not allow harmonisation of national laws in the mentioned areas. Lecture on the article 267 reference procedure in eu law. According to article 26 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu, the union shall adopt measures with the aim of establishing the functioning of the internal market paragraph 1. Free movement of goods european commission europa eu. The union must act within the limits of the competence conferred on it by the member states. This paper aims to analyze the historical development of competition law in the european union, the eu treaties, regulations and directives, which guarantee the protection of competition in the european community. These treaty provisions cover both imports article 34 tfeu and exports article. The polluterpays principle in eu law bold case law and.
Free movement of goods robert schutze european union law. The approximation or harmonisation of member states laws is one of the methods used to achieve this aim. Articles 36 tfeu set out the categories of exclusive, shared and supporting competencies into which eu policies and actions fall. While chapters 2 and 3 have sought to outline the overall procedures and functioning of article 114 tfeu by scrutinising each of its constituent clauses in turn, the current chapter aims instead to assess how the notification procedure within article 11449 tfeu has been deployed in practice. It shall be based on the polluter should pay even though. The article explores the judgment of the court of justice of the eu in case c17111 fra. The four freedoms in the european union when we talk about the european single market and the european union, we should remember that the heart of the community is based on the four fundamental freedoms. The polluterpays principle in eu law bold case law and poor harmonisation 407 pursuant to article 1912 tfeu, union policy on the environment shall aim at a high level of protection taking into account the diversity of situations in the various regions of the union.
The treaty framework for the free movement of goods, laid down in articles 2837 and article 110 tfeu, distinguishes between financial and nonfinancial. Jan 29, 2014 in the seminal case of dassonville the scope of article 34 tfeu was cast very wide, indeed its potential breadth is striking. The courts judgment is particularly notable for its deferential stance towards measures related to. The treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu. Dijon that, in the absence of harmonization of legislation, obstacles to. Within the framework of the provisions set out in this chapter, all restrictions on the movement of capital between member states and between member states and third countries shall be prohibited. Article 345 tfeu ex article 295 ec, its meanings and. Harmonisation is a key concept in the european union for making identical rules in still more areas of governance. Case c57312 alands vindkraft ab v energimyndigheten. The article explores legal questions concerning the content and scope of restrictive measures, the procedure of adopting restrictive measures, the international law context, the legal protection mechanisms as well as the implementation into national law of the eu. The harmonisation model under article 114 tfeu in practice.
Articles 34 and 35 can be used to strike down national legislation which. Article 36 tfeu the provisions of articles 34 and 35 shall not preclude prohibitions or restrictions on imports, exports or goods in transit justified on grounds of public morality, public policy or public security. In the light of this statement, critically discuss the extent to which eu legislation and the case law of the court of justice ensure the free movement of goods in the internal market. Brief regulatory barriers article 34 tfeu rr202 eur. The internal market, four freedoms, article 26 tfeu. The article numbers in the lefthand column correspond to the renumbering provided for in article 5 of, and the annex to, the treaty of lisbon and, consequently, to the numbering used in.
If a measure is not discriminatory because it affects all traders equally then it surely follows that there is no market access problem. Guidelines on the implementation of article 17 tfeu by the. As a consequence, even in the absence of european harmonisation measures secondary eu. Article 345 tfeu, formerly article 295 ec and, before that, article 222 eec, is an article that limits, but not prevents, the application of the tfeu treaty as a whole to the way in which rules of a member state deal with the right of ownership of undertakings. According to article 26 of the treaty on the functioning of. The court held that any measure capable of hindering, directly or indirectly, actually or potentially, intracommunity trade 11 would fall within the scope of article 34, and thus be prohibited. Article 82 tfeu brings mutual recognition in general terms within the scope of the eus competence, and gives in particular the european parliament and the council general regulatory powers on this matter. The union respects and does not prejudice the status under national law of churches and religious associations or communities in the member states. Article 215 tfeu on restrictive measures by gudrun monika. The provisions on the free movement of goods ex articles 2830 ec have remained. Declaration on article 164 of the treaty on european union and article 2382 of the treaty on the functioning of the european union. Article 34 tfeu article through the lens of goods and services. Formerly known as the ec treaty, the treaty of rome or the treaty establishing the european community.
Article 11 ex article 6 tec environmental protection requirements must be integrated into the definition and implementation of the unions policies and activities, in particular with a view to promoting sustainable development. The tfeu is an amended and renamed version of the tec. Southend borough council case c2389 where a a licensing requirement for the sale of sex appliances was held not to breach article 34 tfeu. Article 4 tfeu lists the areas where competence is shared between the eu and the member states, with the area of freedom, security and justice mentioned in article 42j. Consolidated versions of the treaty on european union and the treaty on the functioning of the european union. The union equally respects the status under national law.
A important communications in the area of article 34 tfeu. Free movement of goods in the eu universiteit leiden. Treaty on the functioning of the european union eurofound. This innovative book explores the constitutional compromise between the european unions legislative competence and member states regulatory autonomy, and analyses the reconciliation of economic integration and welfare protection within the european internal market. Seminar on tbt issues eucentral america 2nd round of negotiations. Member states shall respect their independence and shall not seek to influence them in the performance of their tasks. Article 34 tfeu quantitative restrictions on imports and all. The european parliament and the council, acting in accordance with the ordinary legislative procedure, may establish measures to promote and support the action of member states in the field of crime prevention, excluding any harmonisation of the laws and regulations of member states. Directives adopted under this new approach have the dual purpose of ensuring free movement of goods through the technical harmonisation of entire sectors, and guaranteeing a high level of protection of the public interest objectives referred to in article 1143 tfeu e.
204 1349 1558 936 195 188 1282 380 1354 290 1128 871 1214 494 1543 1356 799 1352 710 807 738 1323 227 207 104 576 767 742 90 453 342 445 434 172 1385 76 81 956 274